Hey guys I am currently running BLDC on two 4.12 vesc in my dual 190kv 6374 build. I have heard all this talk of how great FOC is and would love to know your opinion of it. I am not against going FOC and would like to try it but I am completely terrified of killing my vesc!
Where did you get your vescs from and when did you get them?
The reason to check out foc is because it is an ominously beautiful experience accelerating on a silent board. I think I told LHB it was like being pushed by evil spirits.
One is from Chaka and a year old the other I purchased secondhand from LHB. I’m all for a silent ride!
FOC gets louder with speed, but is quieter at lower RPMs. The chaka VESC should be able to handle it especially on 10s. See if you can source the LHB one, I wouldn’t do it with any VESC besides chaka, focbox, or axle.
Then I shall just wait until I go dual FOCBOX!
Ok I have dual FOCBOX and the board is ready to setup. If I decide to go FOC which I want to, what should I be cautious of?
To get FOC running correctly, this is the last step, right? First you set your battery max/min etc in BLDC and do a motor detection?
I have a focbox and ride in Foc its an amazing different between FOC and BLDC… FOC is so quiet on low speed
you Don’t need a BLDC motor detection to run FOC, since it’s a completely different mode than BLDC
Does it make sense to use foc with sensorless SK3 6374 192kv? I have focbox. Would preformance be considerably worse than with a sensor?
Here’s my take…
FOC is fine on the DIY escs on 10s.
what is not fine -no load braking(dont flip the board upside down throttle it and brake while the wheels are moving, test throttle sure just don’t brake) -going faster then your geared speed, if you make it over 60kerpm going downhill and decide to use brakes, your gonna pop your master drv(in dual) and your slave will become non responsive. no brakes!
Thank you for that layout!!! Care to suggest starting values for min and max batt and motor? Dual 6374 190kv, dual FOCBOX, 7" pneumatics, 10s2p 150c lipo, 250# rider.
I have the following set up for
Rider Weight 127lbs Dual 6355 190kv on ackmaniacs firmware this setup is a 10s3p pack that is capable of 60Amps constant current, and 24amps max recharge current(2.5C) the values are divided between two VESCs for a total of the rated power, below is 1 esc
Motor Max 30A Motor Min -30A Battery Max 30A Battery Min -12A ABS Max 130A Watts 1200 Throttle Curve 10.5(25), 45(50), 60(75) - edge sharpness 0
Rider Weight ~185 My friends which is dual 6374 190kv 12s4p and capable of 80A constant current, and 30amps max regen(2.5C), again this is one of two VESC’s
Motor Max 40A Motor Min -40A Battery Max 40A Battery Min -15 ABS Max 130 Wattage 1300w Throttle Curve 15(25), 49(50), 63(75) - edge sharpness 0
So to be clear, I need to half the values between the two focbox? In the past running this setup on BLDC I was running 50a-60a on each motor.
The motor max you can set to whatever you want. Just dont set battery max/min shared between two vesc outside of its constant current limits otherwise you just quickly degrade cells…